Chapter 17
Principles of the Laws Relating to the Transfer of Objects from One Place to Another
THE FOUR CATEGORIES OF PLACE
4.a. Carmelith is a place which
1) is neither reshuth ha-yachid nor reshuth ha-rabbim and
2) has an area large enough to hold a four tefachim by four tefachim square.
4.b. Examples of carmelith are
1) a field,
2) the sea,
3) a desert,
4) a thoroughfare which fails to meet the requirements for reshuth ha-rabbim because, for instance,
a) it is covered,
b) it is less than sixteen amoth wide or
c) an insufficient number of people pass through it, and
5) an area in reshuth ha-rabbim which has the dimensions specified above for carmelith and
a) is at least three, but not as many as ten, tefachim high, or
b) is surrounded by a fence, wall or other partition that is at least three, but not as many as ten, tefachim high.
4.c. Carmelith reaches only to a height of ten tefachim; the vacant space above that is usually treated by Halacha as mekom petur.

